The own vs. rent conundrum my wife and I confronted early in our marriage (33 years this coming year) is well behind us, what with both a primary home and a vacation home in our real estate portfolio today. But with a daughter about to be a university graduate with stable job prospects, we are into the discussion all over again. She and her boyfriend have been blunt: “We don’t want to waste money on renting.”

         My first instinct is to mutter, “Youth is wasted on the young” and then make the case for patience, establishing a career first, maybe investing excess earnings in the stock market or some other money-grower. And yet, when I think about it, I remember the charge I got when I figured out that buying my first home and paying monthly principal, interest and taxes would save me $100 a month compared with my “wasted” rent at the time. (Note: The home was a brand new cedar and stone contemporary on a beautiful, sloping treed lot north of Atlanta that I bought for $43,000. It was 1978. If I had stayed in that home during the full duration of my 30-year mortgage, it would be worth more than $500,000 today.)

         New developers at Bella Collina, the central Florida deluxe golf community originally developed by Bobby Ginn, recently won a local court judgment that clears the way for them to restart development there. One couple has purchased a lakefront lot for $87,000 that originally sold for $1.7 million. We only hope the original owners were able to afford that staggering loss.

         Other property owners who were seduced by the Ginn story of impending riches could not afford the losses. We were especially moved by the story of one of our readers, a police officer in Minnesota who retires next May and whose life was turned upside down by an investment in a Ginn property at Cobblestone Park, just north of Columbia, SC. After paying $265,000 for a lot at Cobblestone in 2005, he and his wife watched the value of their investment virtually disappear in the wake of the Ginn empire’s financial troubles, followed shortly after by the 2008 crash.

Cobblestone Park golf course

The practice facilities at Cobblestone Park are especially good, given that the top-flight University of South Carolina gamecocks golf teams ofter practice there.

 

         “We thought we were in for a sure thing, investment-wise,” says Ray, not his real name. “We expected great returns, money that we would eventually use to help our boys through college.”

         “Now, our boys are stuck with significant student loan debt to follow them for decades. We are now eight years into making monthly mortgage payments [on the lot in Cobblestone], membership dues, HOA fees, and taxes…”

         The family lost more than $240,000 on paper. Recently, D.R. Horton purchased most of the remaining developer properties at Cobblestone Park and made Ray a lowball offer for the lot, which he was willing to accept just to get out from under the carrying charges. But then Horton withdrew the offer shortly after for reasons only a bureaucrat could understand.