Smart Money, the magazine, is not so smart.  It falls into a trap most of the mass media falls into –- it oversimplifies the state of the current housing market, especially those markets that are magnets for retirees, and the magazine falls well short of doing its homework.  Chew, for example, on this bit of wisdom in a SmartMoney.com posting about alternatives to “high-priced” favorite retirement markets:

        “…the real story is in the meteoric rise of real estate prices in retiree-friendly markets:  Despite the national housing collapse, prices in Boulder, Colo., have risen 10% in the last four years, according to Zillow.com, while other cities, like Madison, Wis., have suffered very small declines.  As a result, many of those spots are prohibitively expensive, even after prices have fallen.”

        First of all, “prohibitively expensive” and “prices have fallen” seem incompatible and beg at least for some further explanation, which Smart Money does not offer.  Also, it is sheer lazy journalism to rely solely on Zillow estimates.  Zillow’s property valuations are based on a complicated algorithim and factor in city and county tax records, which have not been universally updated to reflect the downturn in the market.  Neither do they take into account the condition of the homes for which they provide “Zestimates,” and in a time of unprecedented foreclosures and short sales, the Zillow estimates cannot be relied on for accuracy.

        With that said, every once in a while I check the Zestimate on my primary home in Connecticut, but I don’t get too worked up about a jump or drop in value.  Zillow is way more entertainment than gospel.  For an accurate number, hire a professional appraiser.

        My son Tim’s college golf career at Washington & Lee University is winding down to a precious few tournaments, and his mom and I have pledged to attend each one.  The farewell tour took us on Monday and Tuesday to Pine Needles Golf Club, the classic Donald Ross layout threaded through the thick stands of pinus echinata in Southern Pines, NC.  Conditions were challenging, to say the least, with winds gusting to 45 mph on Monday, and a temperature drop of 35 degrees on Tuesday, with winds even more unpredictable than on day one but not as brisk.  The Rossian greens were typically crowned, pushing many of the windy approach shots into collection areas (or worse) and forcing kids who would normally loft their chip shots to scuff a few eight iron shots or even consider putting through winter grass from 10 to 20 yards off the green.

        The Division III golfers did their best to ride the wind on their tee shots and especially their approaches to the slick greens.  The best score on Monday was a 73, outstanding given the conditions and the speed of the putting surfaces; but most scores were above 80, a few well above 80.  Interestingly, the best score under much milder conditions on Tuesday was a 72, although the field racked up far more rounds in the 70s than the day before.  Of course, the downwind holes played longer in the milder winds on Tuesday, but some of the long par 4s into the wind still played long enough.

        Tim shot a 76 on Monday and the above-mentioned 72 on Tuesday, and he earned medalist honors by a single shot over four other golfers.  It was fun to watch.  I will be revisiting the Southern Pines area in a few weeks and will provide a fuller report on the golf course and the surrounding community.  In the meantime, enjoy the accompanying photographs of a classic golf course you can play any time you want.

PineNeedles1stgreen

PineNeedles3fromtee

The par 5 1st hole at Pine Needles (top) is reachable in two, if you avoid the bunkers left and right and keep the ball on a green that tilts left to right.  The short par 3 3rd hole is one of the easiest on the Donald Ross layout -- if you hit your short iron precisely.