Our friend and occasional real estate agent provocateur, Toby Tobin, the publisher of the popular Sunshine State blog GoToby.com, has referenced an interesting article in Business Insider, an online publication with a provocative point of view of its own.  (Today’s headlines include, “Toxic Algae Is Invading The Shores Of A Topless French Beach”).  The serious side to Business Insider includes interesting reports about the housing market, including data provided by the respected FISERV and Case-Shiller market indexes.  The latest report from FISERV and Case-Shiller should put some wry smiles on the faces of Floridians who have watched their home values plummet since 2005.

        According to Business Insider, the data predicts that six of the fastest

The housing data suggest this could be a good time for those whose hearts are set on year round golf in Florida...

appreciating 15 real estate markets across the U.S. are in Florida.  That could be good news for baby boomers with their hearts set on a year round golf community home.  “Nationally, houses are appreciating on [sic] an average of 3.7%,” wrote the editors of Business Insider, who could use a grammar and punctuation lesson, “all of these cities have markets appreciating at over 8%.”

        Lakeland, winter home to the Detroit Tigers baseball club, appears to have a tiger in its tank for the next five years.  It holds down the #6 spot overall on the FISERV/Case Shiller list and should grow home values by 10.3% annually between now and 2016.  Other Florida towns whose home prices are expected to grow impressively are Ocala (#7, 10.1%), Palm Coast (#10, 8.9%), Port St. Lucie and Panama City (tied at #11, 8.8%), and Melbourne (#13, 8.7%).  In citing Lakeland’s strong anticipated price growth, the editors recall that prices there have dropped 55% since the peak of the market.  Lakeland and other Florida cities had defied the laws of gravity for five decades; it was inevitable prices would fall at some point.  But perhaps now the floor has been reached in Lakeland and selected other Florida cities cited in article.

        Unfortunately, gravity and foreclosures keep exerting their pull in two

...but, unfortunately, what happens in Washington doesn't stay in Washington, and the housing markets could be in for even rougher times.

well known Florida cities.  In a separate article entitled “Worst Housing Markets For The Next Five Years,” the data anoints Miami as having the worst prospects for the coming five years.  “If you bought a home in Miami in 2005,” the editors write, “we're sorry:  Over the following six years it depreciated in value by more than 54.3%.”  In the coming five, FISERV and Case-Shiller expect Miami values to erode a further .7% annually.   Nearby Ft. Lauderdale also makes the worst list but can at least look forward to .8% annual growth, paltry after the savaging of recent years but at least it stops the bleeding.

        Back on the “best” markets list, that former mining town of Carson City, NV, tops the entire list, proving if nothing else that there still may be some gold in them thar hills.  The data suggest an annual 11.9% increase in the state capital, and with uncertainty in the equities markets, Carson City could see an influx of real estate speculation.  Of course, we know how that worked out for Miami with all those never-lived-in, foreclosed-on condos.  And before you rush to the Internet to identify a Carson City real estate agent to represent you, consider another headline from the current Business Insider:  “The Debt Ceiling Debacle Is Only The Beginning Of A Major Fiscal Crisis.”

        “If you have the money and plan on staying put for the long term, now may be a good time to buy” a vacation home, according to a recent article in the Wall Street Journal.  As supporting evidence, the article, written by Jessica Silver-Greenberg, refers to National Association of Realtors data indicating that median second-home prices were down an average 25% last year compared with 2006 prices.  Nowhere in the article is there any reference to what effects a potential U.S. default on its obligations would have on the housing market, and specifically on second-home ownership.

        One likely outcome of a default, according to many economists, is that the costs of borrowing money would rise, perhaps significantly.  Those current 5% mortgage loans could conceivably double, making anyone who locks in a low-interest loan today (say, to purchase a golf community home) look like a genius tomorrow.  (I recall my wife and I held a mortgage at a rate of 13.5% in the 1980s.)  The U.S. does not even have to default for interest rates to rise; if the currency markets perceive a half-baked solution to the nation’s ongoing debt issue -– entirely likely to come out of a gridlocked Washington –- an ensuing lack of confidence in the dollar will also drive up interest rates.

        One thing is for certain:  Interest rates are almost assuredly not going any lower, a fact that should give those considering a mortgage to finance a golf vacation home today some small measure of confidence about tomorrow.  However, be aware that the geniuses in Washington have begun talking about a possible elimination of tax deductions on mortgage interest for second homes.  The abandonment of the deduction could result in downward pressure on vacation home prices.  Whether home prices will drop before or after interest rates rise is anyone’s guess at this point.